Foreword Reviews

Cry Wilderness

A bit of a fish story (if fish were replaced with political fisticuffs), Frank Capra’s Cry Wilderness follows a fictionalized Capra to a wilderness cabin in the high Sierra and into local politics, where two long-term hermits-cum-vagrants are being threatened by developer pressures.

Some are intent on rebranding the Sierra region as a high-end vacation destination. Tony Caldwell, a local boy with his sights set on a political career aimed at the White House, spearheads the men’s ouster. But just beneath the surface, a culture war is roiling. Competing interpretations of American values will go to trial as the two sides face off in a heated battle of humanism against the rule of law.

Capra’s elliptical narrative moves through extensive exposition about the Mono Valley before giving way to local politics; much like his movies, it is strongest when it’s character driven. A penchant for soliloquies leads to passages of environmental, philosophical, moral, and political grandstanding. These unbroken orations defy contemporary axioms about dialogue and pacing, but they also reveal much about Capra’s instincts as a director and the underlying social tensions he’s trying to work out.

As narrator, Capra’s a hyperbolic raconteur—boastful, quick-tempered, and insistent. He fights on behalf of the local vagrants yet declares his wife’s “no” a secret “yes” when he touches her. He refers to the indigenous Piutes as lowly, lethargic, and backward while vociferously advocating for primitive wilderness preservation. He rallies local power brokers to the hermits’ cause while exhibiting deep homophobia about a key player’s relationships. He wields his privilege in big swings, and his progressivism is littered with paradoxes.

Fiction is always a response to its own time and place, and when a deceased author’s unpublished manuscript surfaces, a wild and woolly past is unearthed. Cry Wilderness is fiction as time capsule, a “tale full of half-truths, whole-truths, and no-truths at all.”

Reviewed by Letitia Montgomery-Rodgers

Disclosure: This article is not an endorsement, but a review. The author of this book provided free copies of the book to have their book reviewed by a professional reviewer. No fee was paid by the author for this review. Foreword Reviews only recommends books that we love. Foreword Magazine, Inc. is disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255.

Load Next Review