The Sons of Gunshooter
A Navajo Resistance Story
Dorothy Denetclaw and Matt Fitzsimons’s intricate, illuminating history text The Sons of Gunshooter is about Diné life, family lineages, and legal history.
Drawing on extensive archival research, tribal records, and generational oral testimonies, the book reconstructs the circumstances surrounding the 1919 killing of Indian trader Charlie Hubbell and the prosecution of two Diné brothers, situating the case within the larger arc of Navajo-US relations. It frames Hubbell’s death as the culmination of centuries of overlapping relationships, grievances, and cultural misunderstanding.
Beginning by tracing the entwined histories of the Hubbell family and the lineage of Denetclaw’s grandfather, Ahdilthdoney or Gunshooter, before narrowing toward the central events, the book documents the systemic indignities faced by the Diné people, including enslavement that persisted beyond abolition elsewhere in the United States, cycles of internment and displacement, unlawful killings, and forced assimilation through boarding schools and economic coercion. Its work is anchored in a wide range of primary sources, including interview notes, audio recordings, court and prison records, personal correspondence, and interagency communications related to the Hubbell investigation. These materials expose the bureaucratic barriers that Indigenous people were forced to navigate in the twentieth century.
Central to the work is its sustained engagement with Indigenous oral history, which supplies cultural, relational, and spiritual context absent from official records and challenges narrow legal interpretations. The book moves with ease between historical exposition and narrative reconstruction, while an extensive notes section and a selection of archival photographs further support its excellent scholarship.
A compelling work of personal and cultural history, The Sons of Gunshooter reconstructs a family’s entanglement with law, violence, and resilience across generations. In doing so, it demonstrates how a single criminal case reflects enduring negotiations between sovereignty, survival, and state power.
Reviewed by
pine breaks
Disclosure: This article is not an endorsement, but a review. The publisher of this book provided free copies of the book to have their book reviewed by a professional reviewer. No fee was paid by the publisher for this review. Foreword Reviews only recommends books that we love. Foreword Magazine, Inc. is disclosing this in accordance with the Federal Trade Commission’s 16 CFR, Part 255.
